The West Must Ostracize – Not Reward – Hostage Takers

Published originally under the title "The West Must Ostracize Not Reward Hostage Takers."

Winfield Myers

The moral clarity with which President Joe Biden approached the Hamas attack on Israel six months ago is no more. Secretary of State Anthony Blinken and national security adviser Jake Sullivan began backtracking almost as soon as Biden delivered his speech.

Hamas might be a designated terrorist group, but moral equivalence, personal animosity toward Israel’s elected leader, and election-year politics infuses Blinken and Sullivan’sblood. While Hamas could end Israeli operations on Gaza immediately by releasing hostages it has no legal or moral right to hold, Biden’s team rewards the Hamas decision to take hostages by allowing the designated terrorist group to leverage them for concessions. That decision neither brings peace nor does it represent sophisticated diplomacy; rather, it legitimizes terrorism.

Alas, Biden’s willingness to ignore or even reward hostage seizures has become the rule rather than the exception. Azerbaijan continues to hold 55 Armenian prisoners. Some Azerbaijan calls prisoners of war, though this is a misnomer as many are civilians seized from cars at illegal checkpoints or farmers lured or ordered by Azerbaijani soldiers at gunpoint across a demarcated border. Just as Hamas does with Jews, Azerbaijan does not acknowledge many Christians it holds in order to wage psychological terror and to prevent Red Cross visitation.

Like Hamas, Azerbaijan leverages its hostages for diplomatic gain. The White House and State Department, for example, pressured Armenia to drop its bid to host next year’s COP29 environment conference in favor of Azerbaijan as part of a deal to get Azerbaijan to release some Armenian hostages. Biden thereby not only allowed his Azerbaijani counterpart Ilham Aliyev to escape accountability for seizing hostages, but he also gifted him a reward worth hundreds of millions of dollars and the prestige of the international spotlight. Blinken and Sullivan might argue as they did to Armenian officials that allowing Aliyev to get what he wants could advance peace talks, but history shows the opposite to be true: when Aliyev feels empowered and immune, war and ethnic cleansing quickly follow. Blood will flow when the COP29 spotlight fades.

Biden also allows Iran to profit from kidnapping. Hostage-taking is in Iran’s DNA. The 1981 Algiers Accords that presaged Iran’s release of 52 American hostages is a monument not only to rewarding terrorism but also Exhibit A in how succumbing to blackmail guarantees more hostage-taking. Biden’s willingness both to reward Iran with billions of dollars while leaving hostages like Jamshid “Jimmy” Sharmahd behind suggests a disturbing combination of cravenness and the prioritization of short-term ease over long-term consequences. That the hostages Biden ransoms were mostly businessmen who ran afoul of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps while trying to profit from a terrorism sponsor while Iranian security forces kidnapped Sharmahd from outside Iran only adds insult to injury. So, too, does the release of Iranians involved in illicit technology as it establishes false equivalence, betrays the investigators who dedicate their lives to keeping Americans safe, and shows Washington to be unserious about stopping Iran’s nuclear breakout. Indeed, Sullivan’s more than decadelong effort to bring Tehran in from the cold has worsened security, encouraged hostage-taking in Iran and kidnapping of dissidents abroad, and enabled Iran to become a threshold nuclear state.

The pattern repeats with Russia. Not only did Biden reward Russian President Vladimir Putin by trading “merchant of death” Viktor Bout for WNBA star Brittney Griner while leaving a former U.S. Marine to rot, but also, while Biden pays lip service to imprisoned Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich, he ignores Alsu Kurmasheva, a journalist with U.S.-funded Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty.

Silence is never the answer when tyrants and terrorists hold innocent Americans or residents of the United States, like Vladimir Kara-Murza or Princeton University student Elizabeth Tsurkov. Biden’s team may relish the photo-op that comes with a hostage’s return, but the price of blackmail is not worth it. Nor is it necessary. Pastor Andrew Brunson and student Xiyue Wang went free without a single dollar changing hands.

Instead of treating hostages as an irritant to bigger diplomacy, Biden must draw a line: There can be no business as usual so long as innocent Americans remain imprisoned, nor should the United States force democratic allies like Israel or Armenia to reward terrorism. Biden must stop being a tyrants’ dream and start becoming their nightmare.

Michael Rubin is a contributor to the Washington Examiner’s Beltway Confidential blog. He is the director of policy analysis at the Middle East Forum and a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.

Michael Rubin is a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, where he specializes in Middle Eastern countries, particularly Iran and Turkey. His career includes time as a Pentagon official, with field experiences in Iran, Yemen, and Iraq, as well as engagements with the Taliban prior to 9/11. Mr. Rubin has also contributed to military education, teaching U.S. Navy and Marine units about regional conflicts and terrorism. His scholarly work includes several key publications, such as “Dancing with the Devil” and “Eternal Iran.” Rubin earned his Ph.D. and M.A. in history and a B.S. in biology from Yale University.
See more from this Author
The U.S. and Moderate Arab Allies Could Help the Yemenis End the Nightmare of Houthi Rule
There Are Significant Grievances Inside Iran, Especially in Areas Populated by the Arabs, Baluch, and Kurds
The Turkey-Backed Hay’at Tahrir Al-Sham May Be Buying Time Until It Can Consolidate Power
See more on this Topic
I recently witnessed something I haven’t seen in a long time. On Friday, August 16, 2024, a group of pro-Hamas activists packed up their signs and went home in the face of spirited and non-violent opposition from a coalition of pro-American Iranians and American Jews. The last time I saw anything like that happen was in 2006 or 2007, when I led a crowd of Israel supporters in chants in order to silence a heckler standing on the sidewalk near the town common in Amherst, Massachusetts. The ridicule was enough to prompt him and his fellow anti-Israel activists to walk away, as we cheered their departure. It was glorious.