Killings of Hezbollah Leadership Throw Militant Group Into Disarray

Analysts Say They Doubt a New Leader of Hezbollah Will Be Appointed Anytime Soon

Lebanese carrying Hezbollah flags mourn those killed in an Israeli strike.

Lebanese carrying Hezbollah flags mourn those killed in an Israeli strike.

Shutterstock

A series of high-profile assassinations carried out by Israel against the Lebanese militant group Hezbollah in recent weeks has significantly weakened its leadership structure, analysts say.

An Israeli attack killed Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah in Beirut on September 27. Days after that, Israel carried out more airstrikes on Hezbollah’s stronghold in Beirut’s southern suburbs. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Tuesday the Israeli strikes killed Nasrallah’s presumed successor, Hashem Safieddine, even though Hezbollah itself has not confirmed his death.

Since the latest escalation between Israel and Hezbollah, Israeli strikes in Lebanon have killed at least 25 senior commanders of the Shiite group, according to Israeli officials.

Israeli strikes in Lebanon have killed at least 25 senior commanders of the Shiite group.

The absence of these people is evident in Hezbollah’s performance, according to Hussain Abdul Hussain, a research fellow at the Washington-based Foundation for Defense of Democracies, who said the militia “looks headless.”

“Now it still looks operational in the south, but that’s only because Hezbollah designed itself in such a way that if one part is severed, the other parts would continue to operate independently,” he told VOA. “This is good at an operational level, but bad on strategic level.”

Hezbollah leaders claim the group’s capabilities “are fine.” In a televised speech on Tuesday, Hezbollah deputy leader Naim Qassem said Hezbollah’s command and control were intact, and so was its organizational structure.

“We have overcome the blows that hit us, and we have put alternatives for all positions,” he said in his remarks in Arabic, adding that for each newly filled position, a deputy has been assigned.

Qassem said that Hezbollah’s continued rocket attacks on Israel showed a high level of coordination between the group’s leadership and its units.

Israeli officials said Hezbollah fired more than 100 rockets at Israel on Sunday, including several at the northern port city of Haifa. At least five people in Haifa were wounded in the attack.

But analyst Abdul Hussain told VOA via WhatsApp that firing projectiles on Israel was not an indicator of any capabilities, noting that Hezbollah and the Palestinian militant group Hamas are just trying to show they have not been defeated.

“What Hamas does is that every few weeks, it launches at least one or more rockets on Israel to prove that it still has a pulse,” he said. “This does not mean Hamas maintains its control-and-command military structure. The same applies to Hezbollah.”

Hussain added that Hezbollah’s command was centralized, but at times of war, its cells of rocket launchers have a license to act independently when the command is taken down.

Iran’s intervention

Ali al-Amin, a Beirut-based analyst and editor-in-chief of the Janoubia News site, said that what keeps Hezbollah’s military and political structure together and prevents it from further deterioration is a direct intervention by Iran, its main backer.

What keeps Hezbollah’s military and political structure together and prevents it from further deterioration is a direct intervention by Iran.

“Iran no longer believes that Hezbollah is able to manage the confrontation with Israel alone,” he told VOA. “Officials from Iran’s Revolutionary Guard Corps were already here, but more officials and units came to Lebanon after the war erupted to fill the leadership void and reset the structure within [Hezbollah] units on the ground.”

Al-Amin said that Hezbollah is not functioning by its own dynamism as when Nasrallah was alive, noting “the absence of Nasrallah itself has created a major confusion within Hezbollah’s institutions, and Iran wants [to] end confusion by managing the command.”

Qassem, Hezbollah’s deputy general secretary, said in his remarks Tuesday that a new leader for the group will be selected, without setting a specific date.

Given the number of top leaders who were killed in recent Israeli strikes, though, analysts say they doubt a new militant leader will be appointed anytime soon.

“There are no longer figures within Hezbollah that could be compared with Nasrallah, or even with Safieddine,” analyst al-Amin said. “Therefore, I believe that appointing a new secretary general for Hezbollah would take a while.”

“If Hezbollah survived this war and reached a settlement, it could appoint a civilian leader in the next phase,” he said.

This story originated in VOA’s Kurdish Service.

Sirwan Kajjo is a Washington-based journalist and researcher. Since 2012 he has worked at Voice of America as an international broadcaster at the Kurdish service, where he focuses on Islamic militancy, Kurdish affairs, and conflict in the Middle East. Kajjo has written two book chapters on Syria and the Kurds, published by Indiana University Press and Cambridge University Press. He is also the author of Nothing But Soot, a novel set in Syria.
See more from this Author
Despite Its Territorial Defeat in 2019, ISIS Has Been Carrying out Attacks Through Sleeper Cells Across Iraq and Syria
The Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) Said It Attacked the Defense Firm for Its Role in Producing Weapons Used to Attack Kurdish Civilians
In Recent Weeks, There Has Been an Increase in Confrontations Between the Two Sides
See more on this Topic
Returning U.S. President Took Harsh Measures Against the Hague Court in 2020; Biden Reversed Them
The Ruling Issued Marks a Significant Setback for Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and His Associates
Prime Minister Got the Outcome He Wanted in the US Elections