Middle East Forum Islamist Watch senior researcher Mahyar Entezari argues that France’s riots are driven less by immigration or Islamism than by a radical far-left ideology rooted in postcolonial thought. Entezari notes that La France Insoumise, labor unions, communists and revolutionary groups dominate the unrest, citing research by Fox News Digital’s Asra Nomani tracking the groups involved.
Entezari says Islamist influence in France is real but limited, citing a 2025 French Interior Ministry study reported by Le Monde that found about 200 of the country’s 2,800 mosques, roughly 7%, influenced by a Muslim Brotherhood network. He warns that similar far-left calls to dismantle institutions exist in the United States, pointing to the 2020 BLM riots as evidence that such unrest could happen again.
HOST: We’re diving right into it. We’re going to France, where Paris is burning, and we’ve probably all seen the video. I have some B-roll we’ll play in a little bit. But a week ago, or maybe more than a week ago, when I first started seeing this, I was just struggling to understand what is going on. France is no stranger to unrest and to the people revolting. They made ample use of the guillotine decades ago. But they don’t wanna eat cake no more. I don’t know. I guess it is this ideological problem, Islam-immigration riots. Our next guest, Mahyar Entezari. I hope I’m somewhere close on pronouncing that.
ENTEZARI: Yes.
HOST: Great to have you join us. He’s a Middle East Forum senior researcher with Islamist Watch, and he’s the perfect person to try to make sense of what we’re seeing in France now. Mahyar, when I first saw this, I thought, France is obviously running a national deficit. They’ve made cuts to universities and colleges. And I thought it was just kids, 20-somethings, rebelling. French kids. But they seem to be very little of it. What I’m seeing is immigration issues, Islamists. I’m seeing religious clerics, Islamists from Iran, who had predicted years ago that Paris would burn in 2026 and fall to Islam. Is that what is driving this? It’s not the national deficit, it’s not unrest among French teenagers or 20-somethings, it’s immigration? What’s going on over there?
ENTEZARI: Well, hello, and thank you for having me. It’s definitely a very complex situation. I think one shouldn’t ignore immigration, but there’s far more going on. The economic situation is definitely important; I think it fans the flames of unrest and strife. And there’s reportedly at least one Islamist group that’s involved. But I think to focus on the Muslim population, or Islamism, or political Islam, is to overlook a major factor in what’s going on, which is radical far-left ideology. A lot of observers in France and different political parties, even center-left parties and far-left parties, as The Federalist has reported recently, are now also coming out against the far-left party La France Insoumise, LFI, which is promoting these protests. But they’re not the only one. Asra Nomani from Fox News Digital has done the most in-depth research that I’ve seen on tracking the groups that are involved. On Monday she had tracked 54 groups, and just a couple of days ago it went up to 101 groups, in multiple countries now. Only about 33%, one third, are student-led. The rest are adult-led. There are some labor unions, and as Macron has said too, he wants to find other paths for the labor unions to protest. They seem to be the least noxious ones. But there are also communists, radical leftists and revolutionaries involved. And I think the ideology that is very prevalent on the far left is an ideology that lends itself to Islamism. I think it’s rooted in ideas like postcolonialism. France itself has been a breeding ground for a lot of far-left ideologies, like postcolonial thought by thinkers like Frantz Fanon, Jean-Paul Sartre and Michel Foucault. Michel Foucault and Jean-Paul Sartre were French intellectuals who, just to give you a sense of things, celebrated Ayatollah Khomeini coming to Iran. They have this negative view of the West. So these far-left activists who view the West as something to be torn down, I think we’re seeing those ideas being put into action now. And they’re very friendly toward radical Islamists, who also have the same goal. But it should be mentioned that, based on Asra Nomani’s reporting, she identified one group, one student-led group, that reportedly has ties to the Muslim Brotherhood. So it seems that Islamists are a very small part of this.
HOST: Yeah. We have a special guest on, Mahyar Entezari. We’re talking about the unrest in France, these riots, and what is driving them. So the Islam population, the Islam influence, we’ll just call it Islam. I don’t know what kind of immigration policy France has. Very lax, which has allowed a great population... When I was in Paris, probably seven years ago, I noticed that, but I wondered to what degree the Muslim population, the Islam population, is integrating. I don’t think they are. France’s President Macron himself spoke of separatism. They’re living in France, but they still have their own beliefs. And what they’re doing is influencing impressionable, far-left-thinking, liberal-thinking French kids. They’re getting sucked into this, including the viral video, the meme of the shopkeeper who’s saying, “Hey, what are you doing here?” “I’m with you,” she says, and meanwhile the Islam, whoever they are, are saying, “Nah, we’re not with anyone. We’re just here to steal Louis Vuitton bags.” What the...?
ENTEZARI: Well, I think it is important to distinguish between Islamists and just regular Muslims. I personally know some Muslims in France who have integrated. I know a Muslim police officer in France. So there’s definitely a spectrum. Le Monde reported in 2025 that the French Interior Ministry did a study on Islamism in France, and they found that of the 2,800 mosques in France, only about 200, or about 7%, were influenced by a network of the Muslim Brotherhood in France. So the influence is there. It doesn’t represent the entire Muslim population, if we think about 7% of the mosques. However, there are radical leftist ideologues who have spread the idea that to have a revolution you only need something like 8%. You don’t need the whole population. This is far-left rhetoric that I’ve come across before. So 7% is small, but it can have an effect, even if only a small portion of the population is involved. But it’s also important to note that not all of the youth might have fully formed political ideologies; maybe they’re still developing them. And the protests are being led largely by adult organizations. Just to underscore again, the far-left radical ideology is important, because it gives ground for other anti-Western ideas to fester. If we think about how one would integrate immigrant populations: I myself am an immigrant to the United States. My integration happened through the school system, learning to become respectful of America, to love America, and all those sorts of things that I think are important for immigrants to be able to assimilate. But if you have a school system, and a university system too, that’s plagued by ideologies that view the West as something negative, something not to want to integrate into, then that’s not going to be a good recipe for immigrant populations who are coming in and also having these ideas reinforced through the French population, perhaps.
HOST: Mahyar, let me ask you, could France have done anything differently with their immigration policy to avoid this? Are they their own worst problem?
ENTEZARI: Well, I think these recent events underscore the importance of a vetting process, to know who is coming into the country. And I think they have definitely, as we’ve seen, failed at integration. There are the economic factors too. And it’s not 100% the immigrant population. The immigrant population of France is a large chunk of the population, but from the videos I’ve seen, there are also a lot of what we would, how to phrase this, the indigenous French people. We see a lot of them there too who are also involved.
HOST: Yes. And again, sometimes in this discussion we’re painting with a broad brush on who we’re identifying as picking up rocks and throwing them at police. But whatever it is, much of it is driven by some kind of radicalization. And you mentioned there’s no organized endgame. It’s just unrest. Is it the haves and have-nots? Because there are so many different factions of Islam, Muslims. You mentioned about 100 different groups. They’re not of one mindset. They don’t have an endgame in play. What’s the endgame? Take over France? I don’t know, it’s just angst boiling over. What’s...?
ENTEZARI: I think it is hard to see an endgame in violence, because what are they hoping to accomplish by burning things down? If their economy is lagging and they have economic issues, causing all this destruction is certainly not going to make things any better. So it’s counterproductive. There are advocacy groups and labor unions who want to fight for more entitlements. France also has this long-standing tradition of a social safety net, sort of a socialist system. They want more aid from the government. But when we consider again the revolutionary leftists who are also involved: when you have revolution as your goal, the actions you take are just to tear down the system. We saw that when the town hall of Limoges burned down. That sent a signal. The mayor of Limoges said that this is an attack on the Republic. When they say revolution, they mean revolution. It’s not just a word they’re throwing around. They’re trying to overthrow the system. And again, to focus on the Muslim population ignores the radical leftists who are in France, the revolutionaries and communists too.
HOST: Well, I guess the million-dollar question, and break out your crystal ball: this is all happening in Europe, in France. That’s far away. What does the average person in Des Moines, Iowa, care about all this? It’s the implications. Is this a model for the United States? Also a country running a deficit now of, I don’t know, $40 trillion or more. Also a country that has some immigration issues, with significant Muslim, Islam influence, especially in Michigan. Is there a model here, a lesson to be learned for the United States?
ENTEZARI: I think it’s important to take seriously the rhetoric we come across from far-left groups in the United States that say they want to tear things down, that they want to abolish institutions like the Senate. We hear the Democratic Socialists of America say that. I think it’s important to take that seriously, and not to assume that it just can’t happen here. We saw something that looks at least very similar with the BLM riots in 2020. So things like this have happened in the United States before. They could happen again.
HOST: You know, I think the demise of civilization is not going to be some superpower with a nuclear weapon, some country. It’s going to be undefinable groups, whether it’s Yemen’s Houthis or Antifa or Muslim uprisings in Paris, and watching it burn. How do you fight that? How do you even put a finger on and identify what is driving the unrest? And why...
ENTEZARI: I think it’s a matter of knowing exactly what groups are involved and in what capacity. Asra Nomani’s reporting has given us great insight into how many organizations there are and which organizations. But we also don’t know to what extent organizations themselves are driving this and to what extent it’s just individuals, groups of people, and mob mentality. Mobs often don’t need organization; they’re quite the antithesis of organization. And I think one should also remember that there are still millions of Muslims in the West who come to the West wanting to integrate and live peacefully, just like there are millions of people on the political left who also don’t support this kind of thing.
HOST: Yeah. Well, when you see videos like this, news like this, it makes it tough for a regular Muslim, a practicing Muslim, not to be persecuted for who he or she is. It’s just craziness, what’s going on in France. Maybe a lesson. President Trump made a comment a couple of days ago: “Paris is gonna be a Muslim city very soon.” Yeah, it’s concerning. I can’t get my head around it and understand what’s happening. But that’s what guys like this do, and we’re so lucky to have you on to give us some insight. Mahyar Entezari, thank you for joining us.
ENTEZARI: My pleasure. Thank you very much.
HOST: Have a great day.
ENTEZARI: You too.