Like the panel, the audience of approximately 100 represented no coherent philosophy. One young man wore a "gay pride" T-shirt, despite the fact that gay rights are nonexistent in the Muslim world. The crowd, diverse by race, age, and ethnicity, was ideologically monolithic. They appeared to be either leftists ascribing qualities of tolerance and inclusion to Islam, or those who would use leftists to advance a decidedly backward agenda.
After recommending the Twitter hashtag "#MuslimWomenInAction," moderator Jerusha T. Lamptey, assistant professor of Islam and ministry and ISJIE program advisor at UTS, announced that the program would focus on "social justice issues, such as incarceration, climate change, [and] economic inequality, not just Islamophobia."
Lamptey asked, "Can you be a scholar and an activist? Do our institutions permit us to be both?" In fact, institutions become havens for activism only when academic activists alter their scholarly missions.
Declaring ISJIE's goal as the spread of social justice within the parameters of Islam, Lamptey encouraged the audience to ponder, "How . . . we cultivate a cadre of people" into action?
The first speaker, Amina Wadud, professor emeritus of Islamic studies and visiting scholar at the Starr King School of the Ministry, a Unitarian Universalist and multireligious seminary in Berkeley, California, described her personal journey through several religions before eventually stumbling onto Islam.
Wadud was "raised by a Methodist minister," then "made a stop in Buddhism for about a year," before embracing Islam, because, as she put it, "peace and harmony requires promoting justice."
She was feted as the star panelist for her life's work—a peculiar status given that she had difficulty defining what she actually did. Noting that "I work with LGBTQI Muslims," Wadud conceded that, "A lot of my work is unknown" and "only one in ten know my work in my own community." "I'm terrible at the institutional structure in every way, shape or form. I've always been rebellious," she added.
Linda Sarsour, executive director of the Arab American Association of New York, attempted to whitewash history with a fictional narrative of Islam's prophet, Mohammed:
Our prophet was a racial justice activist, a human rights activist, a feminist in his own right. He was a man that cared about the environment. He cared about animal rights.
She then declared, ludicrously: "He was also the first victim of Islamophobia."
He segued to anti-Israel rhetoric without referencing the Jewish state by name: "Any movement that represses anyone else's baby is an insult." Alluding to the United Nations' 1975 resolution equating Zionism with racism and getting the date wrong, he praised 1974 as the year the world condemned "racism, materialism, militarism."
Safi attacked Hillary Clinton for being "a woman who proposes sanctions (on Iran)," for supporting the "continuing oppression in Palestine," and for her "use of drones" before launching a string of self-pitying non-sequiturs regarding professorial finances: "Eighty percent of professors are adjunct [the actual total is seventy percent]. They do not have healthcare. They live below the poverty line." Worse: "I'm a full professor still paying my full undergraduate student loans, and my master loans, and my Ph.D. loans."
Perhaps forgetting the panel's purpose, Safi kept complaining: "Do I write a book that my twelve friends will read if I send a free copy? Or do I want to teach the public?"
Sarsour & DeBlasio
Sarsour, a self-described "Palestinian-American-Muslim, racial justice and civil rights activist," is notorious for tweeting a photo of a rock-throwing Palestinian child with the heading, "The definition of courage." When Jewish Councilman Rory Lancman replied, "No, the definition of barbarism," she eventually responded, "The Zionist trolls are out to play." That her organization is a recipient of taxpayer funding is an outrage.
It was a fitting end to a day of sloganeering against Israel and "Islamophobia," meandering, incoherent rants, and the opportunistic nexus of Islam, feminism, and "social justice." Given platforms such as ISJIE and the audience's eager engagement, the movement to cultivate a cadre of Islamic Social Justice Warriors has launched. Americans should be wary of academic activists bearing "justice."
Eric Golub is a professional author, columnist, and public speaker. This article was commissioned by Campus Watch, a project of the Middle East Forum.