Jake Wallis Simons: The Dangerous Game the U.K. Is Playing with Israel

Jake Wallis Simons, columnist, broadcaster, and author of the 2025 book Never Again? How the West Betrayed the Jews and Itself, co-hosts The Brink podcast with Andrew Fox. Simons spoke to a November 16 Middle East Forum podcast (video). The following summarizes his comments:

Since the U.K. Labour Party’s assumption of power under Keir Starmer in the 2024 general election, the relationship between Britain and Israel has sharply deteriorated, taking a decidedly worse turn with the party’s stance on the Gaza War. This turn was influenced by the success of the “antisemitic” Green Party and the Gaza Independents, “Muslim prospective MPs campaigning solely on antisemitism [and] on Gaza,” in gaining seats. Facing a challenge from the left, British foreign policy towards Israel “quickly went downhill.”

This turn was influenced by the success of the “antisemitic” Green Party and the Gaza Independents, “Muslim prospective MPs campaigning solely on antisemitism [and] on Gaza,” in gaining seats.

In a capitulation to terrorism, in 2024 Starmer joined France’s prime minister Macron and some European countries in recognizing “a state of Palestine” while Israeli hostages still languished in the Hamas tunnels of Gaza. In turn, Hamas offered official congratulations to Starmer’s government for the recognition. When Andy Burnham and his new foreign secretary, Ed Miliband, succeeded Starmer, “Britain” went “lower still” by playing to its leftist base and imposing sanctions on Israel, “ostensibly because of the West Bank settler violence.” Israel responded by banning the British command of the international hub in Israel tasked with overseeing development and security in Gaza. Jerusalem also expelled British diplomats and downgraded its mission.

Economically, Britain’s actions against Israel adversely affected the extensive trade it maintains with the Jewish state. Pharmaceuticals, technology, and defense sectors were all shaken. The ripple effect is that thousands of British workers’ jobs with Israeli companies now hang in the balance. Restricting Israeli intelligence sharing with the U.K. affects the latter’s national security. An attempted bombing of a Royal Air Force base in Britain by Iran was thwarted by a Mossad tip mere days before the U.K. government’s decision to impose sanctions.

The British establishment, vested in promoting a two-state solution, has “lost any kind of sway or influence in Jerusalem” that would further its goal. In order to shore up its left wing and “parade its virtue on the world stage” to foreign leaders and E.U. “centrist fundamentalists,” Britain’s current foreign policy towards Israel is consistent with an international “DEI initiatives” approach. Notwithstanding the potentially catastrophic effect on the U.K.’s economy or its national security interests, cozying up to like-minded world leaders such as France’s Macron, Germany’s Merz, or Canada’s Carney, who also indulge in virtue signaling, is “a kind of feel-good factor that money can’t buy.”

London’s foreign policy is representative of “post-colonial kind of patronizing attempts to lecture the world from our position of moral superiority, while at the same time totally neglecting our own national interests.” At the U.N., Foreign Minister Ed Miliband “waved through” Iran’s appointment to oversee the body involved in counterterrorism and women’s rights, despite having just foiled dozens of Iran-backed kidnapping and assassination plots on Britain’s soil. Yet Miliband imposes sanctions on Israel, an ally whose intelligence agencies helped prevent terror attacks in the U.K. In addition to the adverse effects on Britain’s economy and national security, these sanctions heighten antisemitism and antisemitic actions against British Jewry.

What is unfolding is a “situation where the majority of the country votes for parties of the right, and yet parties of the left get in because the right vote is spread over various parties.”

Post-October 7, hostility towards Israel, and by extension to world Jewry, “has become the norm” and is motivated by “overall ideology and appeasing the far left.” Although Muslims in the U.K. comprise approximately 6-7 percent of the total population, their alliance with progressive radicals gains traction because of the two-party system’s “political fracturing.” Britain’s two traditional political parties, the center-left Labour party and the center-right Conservatives, a.k.a. Tories, are undergoing political instability because of the challenge from the far left and fragmentation of the right. What is unfolding is a “situation where the majority of the country votes for parties of the right, and yet parties of the left get in because the right vote is spread over various parties.”

After World War II and the Cold War’s end, prevention of totalitarianism rested on stopping fascism. Extremism can take root even among those who harbor such positive traits as nationalism, patriotism, respect for national borders, and the flag. In the process of being risk-averse, a “culture of niceism” has replaced the national impulse in the U.K. that was previously occupied by patriotism and self-respect. “Niceism” taught the native population to “suspect our own instincts, to tamp down our own common sense.” Progressive radicals, Islamist radicals and, to a lesser degree, ethnonationalists, filled the vacuum to the point that “radicalism has really gripped a lot of our public debate.”

The West is now firmly in the grip of different strains of radicalism competing for power. There is a silent but sizable portion of Britain and the West that hungers for a return to sensible politics and to reinstate “what Edmund Burke called the pact between the dead, the living, and the yet to be born, that sense of cultural coherence, to return our values to ourselves and to remember what a sane society will look like before it’s too late.”

Marilyn Stern is communications coordinator at the Middle East Forum. She has written articles on national security topics for Front Page Magazine, The Investigative Project on Terrorism, and Small Wars Journal.
See more from this Author
There Are Many Reports of Hezbollah Training Camps in Nicaragua with Lists of Jewish Targets Throughout Latin America
Saudi Arabia Faces a Serious Threat on Three Fronts—the Houthis in the South, the Iraqi Shia Militias in the North, and Iran to Its East
‘We Took Our Foot off the Gas at Just the Wrong Moment’
See more on this Topic
There Are Many Reports of Hezbollah Training Camps in Nicaragua with Lists of Jewish Targets Throughout Latin America
Saudi Arabia Faces a Serious Threat on Three Fronts—the Houthis in the South, the Iraqi Shia Militias in the North, and Iran to Its East
‘We Took Our Foot off the Gas at Just the Wrong Moment’