Middle East studies professors regularly accuse CW and other organizations of “McCarthyism,” an ahistorical, intellectually lazy charge intended to silence critics. Yet days into an ongoing purge of Turkish academics, including 1,500+ deans and four university rectors, the Middle East Studies Association (MESA) has yet to condemn the latest moves by Turkish president Erdogan, whose “moderate Islamism” US profs have long championed as a path to democracy. Will genuine (not imagined) “loyalty oaths” for Turkish academics finally grab MESA’s attention?