Members, Board of Education
San Francisco Unified School District
555 Franklin Street
San Francisco, CA 94102
Dear President Mendoza-McDonnell, Vice President Cook, and Members of the San Francisco Unified School District's Board of Education:
We write on behalf of the Zionist Organization of America (ZOA), the oldest and one of the largest pro-Israel organizations in the U.S., whose mission includes fighting anti-Semitism and anti-Israelism in schools, on college campuses, and other venues.
We, like many members of the San Francisco community, were shocked and outraged to learn that on May 22, you approved a proposal to grant the Arab Resource and Organizing Center (AROC) a contract to provide training and workshops to students in San Francisco's public high schools. Given this group's hateful, divisive and anti-Semitic conduct, it is impossible to fathom how you could have made this decision.
The school district claims to be committed to building school environments that celebrate diversity, reduce prejudice, and enhance understanding between individuals and groups – going so far as to make these commitments in a 2016 resolution. The district expressly committed in the resolution to protect the well-being of all its students and families – which must include those who are Jewish and support the State of Israel.
How in the world, then, can you justify giving AROC a contract to work with and influence your students? AROC openly demonizes and marginalizes those who support the right of Jews to a nation state in their religious and ancestral homeland. AROC makes false accusations against Israel in order to incite hatred of the Jewish state, and it calls for Israel's elimination. Also, AROC supports, praises and glorifies terrorists who have murdered innocent Israeli Jews.
J Weekly has documented AROC's long history of divisive, hateful, and vicious anti-Zionist rhetoric and actions, including the following:
- In November 2014, AROC's executive director, Lara Kiswani, participated in a panel discussion at which she said, "Bringing down Israel really will benefit everyone in the world and everyone in society." She also said, "As long as you continue to be on that side [of Zionism] I'm going to continue to hate you."
- AROC helped lead a 2014 campaign to prevent a ship from unloading its cargo at the Port of Oakland because the ship was partially owned by an Israeli company. In a reference to that campaign, AROC's website said that "business with the racist, exclusionary, Zionist state of Israel, which works alongside local and federal law enforcement to repress our communities, will not go unchallenged."
- AROC blames Jews and those who support a Jewish national homeland for societal problems; the AROC website states, "We believe the global nature of policing and repression is directly related to the relationship between imperialism and Zionism."
- In December 2014, AROC tweeted, "Help us kick Zionism out of the Bay Area. Donate today." This message is evidence enough that AROC's raison d'etre is not to support Arab American and Arabic-speaking students. The group's mission is to demonize and eliminate from the community Jews and others who support Israel.
Among AROC's "honorees" was Rasmea Odeh, a convicted terrorist responsible for murdering two innocent college students in a 1969 supermarket bombing in Israel. Odeh was recently deported from the U.S. for lying about her terrorist crimes on her immigration forms. Yet AROC conveniently omitted these critical facts and actually obscenely claimed that she was arrested and deported from the U.S. as "part of a nationwide sweep against immigrants, Arabs and activists."
AROC's murals also celebrated and praised Leila Khaled, while concealing from the San Francisco community the fact that Khaled is a convicted terrorist who was a key member of the U.S.-designated terrorist group called the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, which hijacked TWA Flight 840 in 1969. A year later, she participated in the attempted hijacking of El Al Flight 219. Over the years, Khaled reportedly has conducted speaking tours across Europe to promote the anti-Israel boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) movement and Israel's elimination.
Please make no mistake about it: AROC's relentless targeting and demonization of Israel and Zionism are anti-Semitic, according to the definition that the U.S. government uses. Educational authorities in California would agree: When the University of California (UC) Regents examined troubling reports of rising anti-Semitism on the UC campuses, the Regents issued a comprehensive report and "principles against intolerance," making it clear that "[a]nti-Semitism, anti-Zionism and other forms of discrimination have no place at the University of California."
Anti-Semitism, anti-Zionism, and other forms of discrimination surely have no place in your schools, either. Think about what AROC did after you approved its proposal: Instead of trying to unify the community, AROC encouraged prejudice and strife against "Zionists" – which many of us understand is code for Jews. The headline on its website screamed this anti-Semitic lie: "Arab Community Wins in the Face of Zionist Attacks!"
The AROC curriculum will supposedly be under the "direct supervision of certified SFUSD staff." But there is no way that district staff can monitor every AROC exchange with every student. District staff cannot guarantee that AROC will not poison the minds of students against Jews and Israel supporters, contrary to district policy. There is little doubt that if the subject of Israel or Zionism comes up in any of AROC's training sessions and workshops, AROC will send a false and negative message to impressionable students.
The district claims that all agencies with a memorandum of understanding must agree to the district's non-discrimination policy. If that is the case, then AROC must publicly and unequivocally renounce all of its anti-Israel and anti-Zionist rhetoric, cleanse its website of all such rhetoric, and publicly apologize for engaging in such discriminatory conduct to this point.
If AROC refuses to do so, then the decision to grant AROC a contract must be rescinded. There are other groups – with records encouraging unity, respect and tolerance, consistent with your school district's values – who would be willing and able to provide classroom workshops related to leadership, development and cultural empowerment.
San Francisco's public school students deserve better than a hateful, divisive group like AROC. You cannot build a supportive school environment free of intolerance, bias and prejudice if you permit AROC to engage with your students.
We look forward to your response and are here to help.
Very truly yours,
Morton A. Klein, National President
Susan B. Tuchman, Esq., Director, Center for Law and Justice
David Kadosh, Executive Director, Western Region