Hamas Isn’t Acting like a Defeated Force, Which Puts the Entire Gaza Ceasefire at Risk

Hamas Seems Determined to Show That It Controls Events on the Ground

Hamas has slow-rolled the release of the 28 slain hostages. By Sunday, it had handed over only 12, six days after the end of the 72-hour window to give up all 28 bodies. Above: Hamas’s Al-Qassam Brigades during the handover of Israeli prisoners to the Red Cross; Deir al-Balah, central Gaza Strip, February 8, 2025.

Hamas has slow-rolled the release of the 28 slain hostages. By Sunday, it had handed over only 12, six days after the end of the 72-hour window to give up all 28 bodies. Above: Hamas’s Al-Qassam Brigades during the handover of Israeli prisoners to the Red Cross; Deir al-Balah, central Gaza Strip, February 8, 2025.

Shutterstock

Standing in front of an adoring crowd at the Knesset last week, US President Trump told Israel’s leaders that “you’ve won” in Gaza.

“What a victory it’s been,” he said in a speech that was maundering even for the famously loquacious president.

Speaking before Trump — hours after the 20 remaining living hostages were released by Hamas — Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was only slightly less triumphant, boasting that Trump’s plan “ends the war by achieving all our objectives.”

“All of the prime minister’s objectives have now been achieved,” his spokeswoman had said three days earlier, as the ceasefire came into effect.

There is one problem, however.

No one seems to have informed Hamas that it has been defeated.

Published originally on October 19, 2025.

Read the full article at the Times of Israel.

Lazar Berman is the diplomatic correspondent at the Times of Israel, where he also covers Christian Affairs. He holds an M.A. in Security Studies from Georgetown University and taught at Salahuddin University in Iraqi Kurdistan. Berman is a reserve captain in the IDF’s Commando Brigade and served in a Bedouin unit during his active service.
See more from this Author
Widespread Unrest Has Revealed the Islamic Republic’s Inability to Address Economic Collapse or Public Anger
A Shock Operation Signals That Long-Standing Deterrence Rules No Longer Apply—and Puts Tehran and Gaza on Notice
The Real Test Of Gaza’s “Day After” Will Be Whether Hamas Faces Any Meaningful Compulsion
See more on this Topic
Preventing Symbolic Triumphs on the Temple Mount Is Central to Deterrence and Postwar Stability
Water Scarcity and Security Cooperation Are Being Weaponized by Rival Elites and Foreign Powers
Contacts Between Displaced Alawite Fighters and the Syrian Democratic Forces Reflect Survival, Not Strategic Coordination