Joel Beinin, a professor of Middle East history at Stanford and president of the Middle East Studies Association, last week circulated an e-mail to “friends and colleagues” urging them to mount a PR campaign on behalf of the association.
“You are probably aware,” Beinin wrote,While the intellectual criticisms of MESA members are mostly mean spirited, ad hominem, and spurious, there is a significant threat to Middle East studies from this assault. Many of the individuals associated with it (Kramer, Kurtz, and Daniel Pipes most prominently) are explicitly calling on Congress to defund Title VI Middle East Centers and to put federal money into building more reliably ‘patriotic’ sources of Middle East expertise. In practice, it would be difficult if not impossible to do this without relying substantially on individuals and institutions already in place. Nonetheless, in the xenophobic current atmosphere of the United States, we would be seriously remiss if we failed to make a public case for the value of our scholarly enterprise not only for its own sake, but also for the public goods it provides to American society at large.
The September 11 attacks revealed that the vaunted “expertise” of the MESA establishment was no such thing. Theirs is a tendentious, ideologically driven lefty academic enterprise. In Kurtz’s unsparing phrase, an “intellectual failure.” Kurtz summarized Kramer’s findings in these pages last November (“The Scandal of Middle East Studies,” November 19, 2001):
This question has received its condign rejoinder in the works of Kramer, Kurtz, and Pipes. They ask, in effect: Should not the U.S. government “keep skeptical” about MESA’s assessment of the terrorist threat? To what extent did academic Middle East “experts” indirectly contribute to our unpreparedness for bin Laden by focusing too little on horrible scenarios that, alas, were not at all far-fetched?
So how does Beinin think MESA should answer this critique? Apparently by caricaturing it: “We should actively advocate the idea that lively discussion of Middle Eastern affairs, not slavish parroting of whatever pronouncements come from Washington policy makers, is the best way to promote good public policy and an informed citizenry.”
Revealingly, Beinin’s first two suggestions of specific outlets for MESA’s new PR offensive are the lefty outfits AlterNet and Pacific News Service. The case for defunding only gets stronger.