Why Hamas’ Attempt to Start a Third Intifada Will Likely Fail

Originally published under the title "A Third Intifada Is Unlikely, but Hamas Is Trying to Start One."

Arabs in (clockwise from top left) Israel, Jerusalem, the West Bank, and Gaza have different interests and political outlooks.

Excerpt

The Israeli Jewish and Palestinian Arab populations west of the Jordan River are roughly of equal size. But while Israeli Jews are gathered under a single political authority and structure, the Arab population is divided into four distinct groups: Arab citizens of Israel, Arab residents of Jerusalem, the population of Gaza, and the population of the West Bank under the Palestinian Authority.

These publics are mostly united by a common Islamic religious identity, and to a lesser extent by a common sense of Palestinian nationality. But their immediate interests and political outlook diverge in important ways.

The question is whether the passions aroused around the supposed threat to the Al Aqsa mosque will override the differing outlooks and interests, and whether a large part of the Arab population west of the Jordan River will launch an uprising against Israel. Hamas is pushing in that direction, in the waning days of Ramadan. But the shift of the epicenter of events to Gaza may limit the impact of this effort. Gaza is not a unifying symbol. The West Bank is so far largely quiet. In Jerusalem and among Arab Israelis, the unrest, while fierce, remains geographically limited and involves limited numbers. For as long as these divisions hold, there’s little chance of a third intifada.

Read the full article at wsj.com>

Jonathan Spyer is a Ginsburg/Milstein Writing Fellow at the Middle East Forum and director of the Middle East Center for Reporting and Analysis.

Jonathan Spyer oversees the Forum’s content and is editor of the Middle East Quarterly. Mr. Spyer, a journalist, reports for Janes Intelligence Review, writes a column for the Jerusalem Post, and is a contributor to the Wall Street Journal and The Australian. He frequently reports from Syria and Iraq. He has a B.A. from the London School of Economics, an M.A. from the School of Oriental and African Studies in London, and a Ph.D. from the London School of Economics. He is the author of two books: The Transforming Fire: The Rise of the Israel-Islamist Conflict (2010) and Days of the Fall: A Reporter’s Journey in the Syria and Iraq Wars (2017).
See more from this Author
Imprisoned PKK Leader Abdullah Ocalan’s Declaration of a Ceasefire Does Not Indicate The Conclusion of the Long Conflict with the Turkish State
As a Result of Recent Experience in Gaza, Israel’s Preference Is Now for Buffer Zones on Hostile Borders
See more on this Topic
I recently witnessed something I haven’t seen in a long time. On Friday, August 16, 2024, a group of pro-Hamas activists packed up their signs and went home in the face of spirited and non-violent opposition from a coalition of pro-American Iranians and American Jews. The last time I saw anything like that happen was in 2006 or 2007, when I led a crowd of Israel supporters in chants in order to silence a heckler standing on the sidewalk near the town common in Amherst, Massachusetts. The ridicule was enough to prompt him and his fellow anti-Israel activists to walk away, as we cheered their departure. It was glorious.