Honest Disagreement, or Anti-Semitism? [on Juan Cole]

University of Michigan Professor Juan Cole yesterday discussed accusations of anti-Semitism directed against him, accusations he thinks are unfair.

Perhaps Cole might consider the ease with which he accuses people of dual loyalty. Too often, it seems that Cole cannot conceive that anyone can honestly disagree with his analysis, for example, about what constitutes a U.S. national security interest. For me, any partner’s trust in alliance with the United States—be it Israel, or Taiwan, or Georgia—has a greater value than either Cole or, for that matter, Harvard Professor Stephen Walt are willing to accept. However, since Cole cannot conceive of honest disagreement, then those who do not share his opinions must hold foreign loyalties. That represents quite a leap of logic on Cole’s part, one that he employs to avoid analyzing what detractors say, write, or believe. In theory, academicians should be precise and careful; they should base their labeling of others on evidence, not supposition. Perhaps Cole and his fellow-travelers believe it’s not anti-Semitic to consider any Jew who does not share their opinions to harbor loyalty with a foreign political party. If so, then it certainly reflects an arrogance about the righteousness of one’s own views, an antipathy toward anyone who would challenge those views, and a willingness to stifle debate.

Michael Rubin specializes in Iran, Turkey and the Horn of Africa. His career includes time as a Pentagon official, with field experiences in Iran, Yemen, and Iraq, as well as engagements with the Taliban prior to 9/11. Mr. Rubin has also contributed to military education, teaching U.S. Navy and Marine units about regional conflicts and terrorism. His scholarly work includes several key publications, such as “Dancing with the Devil” and “Eternal Iran.” Rubin earned his Ph.D. and M.A. in history and a B.S. in biology from Yale University.
See more from this Author
Both United Nations Agencies Have Done More to Harm Refugees and Keep Conflict Alive than to Help and Resolve
Turkey Now Exploits Somalia Akin to How the French and Belgians Treated Their Colonial Territories
Turkey’s Advocates May Acknowledge Its Misbehavior, but They Often Argue That the Price Is Worth It
See more on this Topic
End ‘Crazy State’ Israel’s ‘Silent Apartheid’ with a Single State Solution
UChicago’s Former Middle East Center Director Teaches Sinwar and Roots for Tehran’s Missiles
‘The Reality Was Far More Complex and Was Primarily Related to the Widespread Opposition to American Policy in the Middle East’