On Aug. 21, the New York City Council announced $250,000 in grants made to 14 Muslim community organizations in collaboration with the New York Immigration Coalition. Alarmingly, three of the grant recipients are linked to Islamic extremism — the Council on American Islamic Relations (CAIR), the Muslim American Society (MAS), and the Islamic Circle of North America (ICNA).
Worse, it seems that the ICNA in particular plans to use the money for religious proselytizing rather than civic improvement
The grant announcement was made at ICNA's headquarters in Jamaica, Queens, after the Jumu'ah prayer service. Present were the young speaker of the city council, Corey Johnson, and Councilman Daneek Miller, the sole Muslim member of the council.
Councilman Miller is no stranger to the ICNA; his campaign website prominently features a photo of him speaking at the ICNA mosque.
ICNA was established in 1971, ostensibly as a "non-ethnic, non-sectarian" grassroots organization, with the aim of seeking the "establishment of the Islamic system of life as spelled out in the Qur'an."
In fact, it functions as the American arm of the Pakistani Islamist group Jamaat e-Islami (JI). Indeed, ICNA's international charity, Helping Hand for Relief and Development (HHRD), works closely with JI in Pakistan. Worse, in 2017 HHRD openly worked with the "political" wing of the murderous terror group Lashkar-e-Taiba.
JI has long been linked to political violence, notably during the Bangladesh War of Independence in 1971 — during which Pakistan employed JI groups as death squads. ICNA's former Vice President Ashraf Uzzaman Khan was convicted in absentia by Bangladesh in 2013 of being part of the Pakistan-backed Al-Badr death squad, and personally murdering seven professors and intellectuals.
The radical literature of JI's founder, Sayyid Abul 'Ala Maududi, is repeatedly emphasized in the 2010 ICNA members' handbook, which explicitly discusses ICNA's true goal of setting up a worldwide Islamic state via proselytizing campaigns.
Unsurprisingly, ICNA secretary general Muhammad Rahman said that ICNA's portion of the grant money would fund "community engagement activities;" he specifically mentioned "Iftar in the Park" and outdoor prayer services.
To pay for prayer services with a government grant is a blatant violation of constitutional law, all the more so when it is to proselytize.
MAS, meanwhile, has been identified in courtroom testimony as the main U.S. front group for the Muslim Brotherhood. And CAIR was founded by the leaders of the Islamic Association for Palestine, a front group for Hamas, following the 2007 Holy Land Foundation trial featuring strong evidence that CAIR was still coordinating with Hamas. The FBI subsequently cut off all contact with CAIR.
CAIR's New York chapter has been particularly open in its support for terrorism. Former executive director Cyrus McGoldrick has a history of inflammatory rhetoric, including retweeting a statement from Hamas leader Khaled Meshal mocking those who object to its rocket attacks on civilians, and other tweets quoting Hamas slogans.
CAIR-NY board member Lamis Deek publicly praised a Palestinian drive-by murderer, calling him a "martyr," and bluntly stating that the "Zionist Israeli government does not have the right to exist." She was even more explicit in 2009: "[I]n choosing Hamas, what [the Palestinian people] chose was one united Palestinian state on all of the 1948 territories from the north to the very south.… [And] we support their right to liberation from violent colonialism."
New York's new grant program likely reflects the increasing influence that CAIR has in City Hall. CAIR-NY President Zead Ramadan is a significant donor to New York politicians including Mayor Bill DeBlasio and Faiza Ali, the director of Speaker Johnson's office and formerly the community affairs director of CAIR-NY (as well as a civic engagement director for the Arab American Association of New York, which also received grant money).
Speaker Johnson, a councilman from Manhattan, also owes his current position to the support of the Queens and Bronx Democratic machine (to which he has directed considerable pork); this may help to explain his willingness to associate himself with Queens-based groups like ICNA.
It is shocking that an effort to strengthen local Muslim communities is being exploited to fund groups linked to extremism. Sleazy pay-for-play politics do not excuse such reckless policy, nor do they excuse violating the Constitution by funding religious services.
If New Yorkers want to help Muslim communities, giving money to CAIR, ICNA, and MAS should be the last thing they do.
Dr. Oren Litwin is a Research Fellow at Islamist Watch, a project of the Middle East Forum.