Gov. Rick Perry and Democratic challenger Bill White agree that while plans to build a mosque near Ground Zero have stirred controversy, they don’t object to a local decision affirming the Islamic group’s right to build it.
A New York City planning commission voted this week to clear the way for a planned Islamic community center and mosque near the site of the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks.
Opponents say the project is an insult to the memory of the nearly 3,000 people killed at the site. A conservative advocacy group has filed suit seeking to stop construction.
The plan has become an issue nationally, and in Texas, where private property rights, the authority of government and local control are all issues in the race for governor.
Perry, who has campaigned on states’ rights and local control, said he would prefer that planners find another site far from Ground Zero. But he supports the right of local citizens to authorize it.
“I’m a big believer in freedom of religion but believe it would be best for all involved to put the facility elsewhere,” Perry said. “However, zoning is a local responsibility and as a staunch supporter of the 10th Amendment, I do not think the federal government should take steps to intercede or overrule the wishes of local residents. The citizens of New York City will decide the fate of this building.”
In a written statement, White took no position on the proximity of a mosque to the attack site, but he agreed that the decision is a local matter.
“I’m focused on Texas and talking with Texans every day about how we can improve our schools and attract good jobs to the state,” he said. “The people of New York City, not people outside the state, should make decisions on building permits and any land use regulations.”
The debate over the Islamic center has underscored a clash between religious freedom and the legacy of the Sept. 11 attacks.
Although opponents have filed suit, city attorneys say they are confident the landmarks group adhered to legal standards and procedures.
The group behind the $100 million project, the Cordoba Initiative, describes it as a Muslim-themed community center. Early plans call not only for prayer space but for a swimming pool, culinary school, art studios and other features.
Some prominent Republicans including former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin and former House Speaker Newt Gingrich have criticized the plan - as has the Anti-Defamation League, a Jewish civil rights group known for advocating religious freedom.
Supporters of the planned Islamic center see it as a monument to tolerance and religious liberty.