Queensland Premier Campbell Newman backs magistrate’s rights to decide whether Islamic woman should wear full-face burqa in Brisbane court

Queensland’s Premier has defended the right of judges to decide what people should wear in their courtrooms, after a Brisbane magistrate questioned whether a Saudi woman should have been allowed to wear a full burqa.

John Costello was sentencing the woman for leaving her baby unattended in a hot car for 45 minutes last year, when he raised concerns about her religious attire.

“This is an Australian court,” Mr Costello said.

He also queried the validity of the woman wearing the burqa in court.

Today Premier Campbell Newman said the matter was something for “judges to make a call on”.

“I’m not about to intrude on the independence of courts,” Mr Newman said.

“I think the judges themselves are the ones who are the masters of their courtroom and they have a right to decide whether justice is served by people wearing that sort of head dress or otherwise.

“They have to be able to see people give evidence and the like in front of them.”

This morning, The Courier-Mail reported a magistrate had questioned whether a Saudi woman appearing in court should have been allowed to wear “a full burqa” or face covering, telling her “this is an Australian court”.

Brisbane Magistrate John Costello was sentencing a woman who pleaded guilty to leaving her baby, four and half months, unattended in a car in direct sun for 45 minutes last year.

Mr Costello asked the woman’s lawyer Peter Saggers if what she was wearing was “a full burqa” and he indicated it was.

“I can only see the eyes of that defendant,” Mr Costello said.

The magistrate questioned whether it was “appropriate” for the full burqa to be worn in court, saying: “This is an Australian court” and he queried “the validity” of her wearing it in court.

But Islamic groups yesterday came out in support of Mr Costello, saying they supported magistrates asking women to remove their face covering if there was a reasonable question of security or identification.

Mr Saggers told the magistrate the woman, 27, was from Saudi Arabia and said: “I have not seen her dressed in any other way.”

Mr Costello then proceeded to sentence the female student, without requiring her to remove her face covering, more commonly called a niqab when it reveals the eyes.

Islamic Council of Queensland president Mohammed Yusuf said he opposed any blanket law requiring women wearing burqa or niqab to show their face.

But he said the Islamic council would not object to a magistrate asking a woman to remove her face covering if there was a reasonable question of security or identification.

Mr Yusuf said individual cases could be handled with sensitivity, with the woman taken into another room for identification by a female police or court officer.

Yasmin Khan, president of Islamic community festival Eidsfest, said magistrates should be able to ask women wearing a burqa or niqab to remove their facial covering in court.

“Where justice and security are an issue women should identify by at least showing their face, to identify the person who has been charged,” Ms Khan said.

She said another person could falsely pose as an accused person by wearing a face covering.

Nearly three years ago a Perth judge caused controversy when she ordered a Muslim woman to remove a full burqa while giving evidence before a jury in a fraud trial.

“Judges and magistrates are acutely alive to the sensitivity of these situations. They respect the requirements of particular religions,” Queensland Chief Justice Paul de Jersey said yesterday.

“They would request removal of a burqa only if necessary for the due determination of a proceeding - if, for example, the identity of an alleged offender were in issue.”

Deputy Anti-Discrimination Commissioner Neroli Holmes said the Anti-Discrimination Act did not apply to court directions.

She said it was not unlawful discrimination to respectfully ask someone to remove headwear if it was required “for purposes of reasonable legitimate public safety or identification”.

An Islamic woman should be asked to remove her headwear in a respectful way and not in the presence of men, where possible, Ms Holmes said.

A Brisbane Muslim teenager recently complained to Queensland’s Anti-Discrimination Commission of being held against her will in a service station, after refusing to remove her full burqa.

In yesterday’s court case Mr Costello sentenced the woman to a six-month good behaviour bond.

The court heard the woman and her husband, who also was charged, left their baby in the car, in direct sunlight with windows wound up, for 45 minutes. A nurse called police.

See more on this Topic