American protestors violently beaten by Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan's security detail in May 2017 are finally experiencing justice after a federal court rejected Turkey's request to dismiss a civil lawsuit targeting the perpetrators.
Video evidence showed Turkish security officials attacking demonstrators, including women and elderly, outside the Turkish ambassador's residence in Washington D.C. This was the latest altercation involving the presidential security team, which has skirmished with American journalists, law enforcement, and demonstrators during recurring state visits.
During a more recent state visit, it seems that Erdoğan has supplemented his misfit bodyguard detail with an Islamist neighborhood watch group that is mired in controversy. On September 22, the Brooklyn-based Muslim Community Patrol and Services (MCPS) provided protective services for the Turkish dictator while he addressed members of the Turkish American National Steering Committee (TASC) at the Hilton Midtown Hotel ballroom.
An MCPS official was also present at the attack on demonstrators in 2017, although it is unknown whether MCPS was involved in the violence.
At the TASC event in 2019, "MCPS was there to provide support, security and crowd management" for the Turkish president, claimed the group's Facebook page.
Fliers promoting the September event titled it "Uniting the Ummah" -- a reference to the global Muslim community. Erdoğan was in town to forge ties with American Islamists who increasingly view the Turkish despot as their "new Caliph," or the rightful leader of the "Islamic world." The hosting body TASC is the unofficial proxy of Turkey's conservative Justice and Development Party (AKP), and its members make no attempt to hide their singular loyalty to Erdoğan, calling him "our president."
MCPS, which bills itself as a civilian patrol organization acting as a liaison between New York police and the local Muslim community, typically patrols Brooklyn's Bay Ridge and Sunset Park neighborhoods. One MCPS leader called the group a "neighborhood community patrol on steroids," and residents have complained about its overzealous nature. Besides driving around in patrol vehicles that look remarkably similar to New York Police Department cruisers, MCPS recruits have been accused of harassing residents for minor offenses, and they are allegedly involved in a feud with the local Gates Avenue Bloods, a violent street gang. (MCPS head of security Ali Karim denied this altercation, referring to the sources of the allegation as "human devils.")
Staffed by amateur volunteers, MCPS may not seem like Erdoğan's best option for supplemental security. However, by employing MCPS, the Turkish regime is expanding its base of overseas Islamist loyalists, who can subsequently be called upon to support his political objectives.
While cementing his authoritarian reign at home, Erdoğan has long been leveraging his international ties to Islamists. He openly backs the Muslim Brotherhood. His regime has provided financial support for Hamas, a designated terrorist group, and is accused of supporting affiliates of terrorist groups such as ISIS and Al Qaeda.
On the American front, Erdoğan and his advisors regularly attend conventions organized by Islamist groups with extremist ties, such as the Council on American-Islamic Relations and the Islamic Society of North America. Recently, Turkey invested $110 million in building a 20,000 square foot mosque in Maryland. In response, Islamists openly pledge their support to the Turkish president, treating him "like a Sultan" in exchange for increased financial and political support.
With documented ties to terrorism and extremism of their own, MCPS leaders apparently harbored no reservations about lending their support to a foreign Islamist leader. In fact, MCPS security chief Ali Karim claimed that he "witnessed" the 2017 Sheridan Circle assault "first hand," but still felt at ease working in September with the Turkish president's violent security detail.
Karim is the spokesman and head of security for extremist preacher and senior MCPS leader Siraj Wahhaj's At-Taqwa mosque, where Karim hosts self-defense workshops offering paramilitary-style training and instructions on how to disarm law enforcement officers. Several workshop participants have referred to themselves as "jihad warriors," and one trainee pleaded guilty in 2011 to plotting an attack on the Washington D.C. Metro System. In a 2013 social media post, Karim wrote, "Allah made it obligatory for the Muslims to fight in Jihad against the evil of the enemy who transgress against Islam ... Jihad is required from every person."
According to official NYPD documents, local law enforcement maintained a special interest in Karim and Wahhaj, secretly monitoring them for years.
Wahhaj's speech at the September TASC event praised the Turkish president. "We need a centralized leadership. I have a feeling that the leadership is coming from Turkey," Wahhaj said, adding, "We love you here in New York."
Wahhaj, the MCPS deputy director of operations, was listed as a potential co-conspirator in the 1993 World Trade Center bombing. During the late 1980s, Wahhaj began recruiting Muslims from prisons and homeless shelters to eradicate crack dealers from Brooklyn. "We are willing to fight, willing to die and willing to kill," Wahhaj told the New York Times.
Wahhaj's men were eventually absorbed into SSI Patrol Services, an armed private security firm frequently in trouble with the law. At least three SSI guards were charged with serious criminal offenses, including second-degree murder. The defendant in that case, Ali Mustapha, was acquitted after one key witness was murdered and another refused to testify. Mustapha currently serves as MCPS's recruitment officer and supervisor.
Impetuous and extreme, MCPS members make for poor public safety officers. Perhaps for these reasons it was selected to reinforce a Turkish presidential security detachment with its own history of brutality and contempt for U.S. laws.
The presence of uniformed Muslim American guards deployed in service to a foreign leader sends a clear message to the world: a growing number of American Islamists are fiercely devoted to Erdoğan as the Caliph of an Islamic state that has transcended national borders.
Karys Rhea is a Counter-Islamist Grid Fellow of the Middle East Forum. Benjamin Baird is the Deputy Director of Islamist Watch, a project of the Middle East Forum.