After Somalia Debacle, Should Anyone Trust Turkey as Counterterror Partner?

Turkey’s Advocates May Acknowledge Its Misbehavior, but They Often Argue That the Price Is Worth It

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan in a file photo.

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan.

Shutterstock

There is a paradox to Turkey today. On one hand, President Donald Trump increasingly relies on Turkey as a surrogate to maintain order in the Middle East and Eastern Mediterranean. On the other, Turkey’s own actions destabilize the region.

Turkey is a problematic ally. President Recep Tayyip Erdoǧan’s support for Hamas goes beyond advocacy. Hamas now is as likely to plan terrorism against Israel from Turkey as it is Iran. Turkey also rationalizes, supports, and profits from Al Qaeda affiliates and the Islamic State. Turkey’s occupation over northern Cyprus festers as Iranian proxies and Sunni extremists both use the occupied zone’s casinos and colleges to launder money and smuggle men. More recently, Erdoğan’s billionaire son Bilal sought to undermine Lebanon’s moves toward peace with Israel.

As Trump considered utilizing Kurds to carve out a zone from which the Iranian opposition could organize, Erdoğan allegedly threatened to help Iran.

Turkey’s Libyan client, Abdul Hamid Dbeibeh, harbors both the next Osama bin Laden and militiamen wanted in the 2012 attack on the U.S. consulate in Benghazi. Turkey’s grab of Mediterranean territorial waters rivals Beijing’s South China Sea hubris. Whereas Turkey’s supporters often rationalize Turkey’s S-400 purchase as symptomatic of Erdoğan’s transactionalism, such opportunism is now more the rule than the exception. Erdoğan held NATO hostage to extract concessions before lifting his veto on Finland and Sweden’s accession; more recently, he repeated the pattern with China, embracing Huawei and a new $15 billion energy infrastructure plan. As Trump considered utilizing Kurds to carve out a zone from which the Iranian opposition could organize, Erdoğan allegedly threatened to help Iran. Earlier, Turkey had betrayed to Tehran a network of Israeli spies working on Iran’s nuclear program.

Turkey’s lobbyists and advocates in the think tank world may acknowledge Turkey’s misbehavior and misalignment of goals, but they often argue that the price is worth it. Trump argues that deferring regional security to Erdoğan frees up limited U.S. resources to focus on areas of greater strategic concern. By such logic, betraying Syrian Kurds, Armenian Christians, or remaining silent on the occupation of Cyprus was just a necessary evil.

Recent events, however, suggest that trusting Turkey to keep its end of the bargain is foolish. Consider Somalia: Turkey has largely taken the lead in Somalia, controlling the international airport, running the port, and training the anti-terrorism forces. Turkish officials say they do so to protect Somalia from al-Shabaab, though, in reality, Turkey’s behavior is more colonialist, extracting Somali resources and propping up the president in exchange for his willingness to serve as a rubber stamp.

Word has leaked that the Somali commander of the Turkish-trained Duufaan unit defected to al-Shabaab with laptops, communication equipment, and confidential files.

Turkey, however, has failed to secure Somalia, at least in the way that its Western partners envision. Turkey’s support for the Laascaanood insurgency opened the door for al-Shabaab expansion. Somalia’s implementation of an e-Visa system has been disastrous, with critical data about applicants leaking. Now, word has leaked that the Somali commander of the Turkish-trained Duufaan unit defected to al-Shabaab with laptops, communication equipment, and confidential files.

In effect, it is déjà vu all over again. Turkey previously flirted with the Islamic State, only to have the group rapidly expand its control and blowback with attacks inside Turkey itself. In the Duufaan case, there are two possibilities: First, Turkey’s vetting was incompetent; it does not know in whom it places its trust. Second, and just as likely, Turkey sought to promote terror sympathizers, falsely believing it could keep them under control.

In theory, Erdoğan’s bargain may make sense to Trump. In reality, Erdoğan’s refusal to stop his promotion of Islamist extremism makes entrusting Turkey as a security surrogate the diplomatic equivalent of hiring a serial arsonist to run the fire station.

Michael Rubin specializes in Iran, Turkey and the Horn of Africa. His career includes time as a Pentagon official, with field experiences in Iran, Yemen, and Iraq, as well as engagements with the Taliban prior to 9/11. Mr. Rubin has also contributed to military education, teaching U.S. Navy and Marine units about regional conflicts and terrorism. His scholarly work includes several key publications, such as “Dancing with the Devil” and “Eternal Iran.” Rubin earned his Ph.D. and M.A. in history and a B.S. in biology from Yale University.
See more from this Author
It Is Essential That the Somaliland Government Regulate the Big Two Financial Firms Now, No Matter How Furiously They Lobby to Avoid It
The American Friends Service Committee Always Had a Blind Spot Toward Palestinian Violence as Its Members Demonized Israel
Israel Recognizes It Faces an Existential Crisis
See more on this Topic
Ankara Must Insist on Firm Financing and Clear Deadlines, and Keep Control of Sensitive Infrastructure with Turkey
Three Decisive Measures Have the Potential to End the Silence That Has Haunted the Arad Family Since 1988
Iran Has Failed to Develop Sufficient Alternative Sources or Build the Infrastructure Needed to Cope with Demand