Hatred of Jews and Israel is on the rise at McGill University in Montreal.
Hatred of Jews and Israel is on the rise at McGill University in Montreal.
At one of Canada's elite universities, McGill University in Montreal, a series of disturbing anti-Semitic incidents have drawn wide attention and unsettled Jewish students.
There have been repeated campaigns by the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement against Israel, the homeland of the Jewish people.[i]The McGill Daily student newspaper has an established policy of rejecting any article supporting or defending Zionism, the national movement of the Jews, or presenting Israel in any but a negative fashion.[ii] Most recently, in response to the failure of the BDS movement to be validated at McGill, disappointed supporters voted down three nominated members of the Student Society Board of Directors, one Jewish and two not, on the grounds that their ties to Jewish organizations and supportive attitudes toward Israel made them biased.[iii]
Some Canadian Jewish organizations have raised concerns about this, and, for its own part, the McGill administration, which does not support the BDS movement and favours inclusiveness, has launched an investigation.
Anti-Semitism, or Jew-hatred, is not a new phenomenon. For two thousand years there was an element of anti-Semitism in Christianity, with Jews being blamed for rejecting the Messiah, and for the death of Jesus. Anti-Jewish texts can be found among both Catholics and Protestants, most notably among the latter, the work of Martin Luther.[iv]But traditional Christian anti-Semitism gradually declined in Western Europe and most of North America, although not in Eastern Europe or Quebec, with growing secularism in the 19th and 20th centuries. After World War Two and the Holocaust, anti-Semitism became unfashionable in Western Europe and North America, while secularism in Quebec came later, during the Quiet Revolution of the 1960s. Nonetheless, in both the U.S.[v] and Canada,[vi] hate crime against religion has traditionally overwhelmingly targeted Jews.
Today, hatred of Jews is reflected in the demand that Israel, in effect, be destroyed.
In the 21st century, anti-Semitism has taken a new form – hatred of the Jewish collectivity, of the Jewish people in their collective representations, particularly hatred of Israel. This is not a matter of criticism of government policies of Israel, as one might make of policies of the U.S., Russia, or China. Rather, this hatred of Jews is reflected in the demand and intention that Israel be destroyed. We hear this regularly from Iran, from Palestinian Hamas, from Hezbollah, and, more stealthfully from Palestinian Fatah and the Palestinian Authority, as well as from the supporters of these organizations. Hatred of Jews is also manifested in identifying Jews as the font of all evil in the world, which is common among Imams during mosque sermons, as well as in the intention to cleanse the world of all Jews: "the Islamic Resistance Movement aspires to the realisation of Allah's promise, no matter how long that should take. The Prophet, Allah bless him and grant him salvation, has said: 'The Day of Judgement will not come about until Moslems fight the Jews (killing the Jews)....'"[vii] Hatred is seen in the double standard applied to Israel, in which it is uniquely condemned for crimes against humanity, without ever considering other states such as Iran, China, Russia, Saudi Arabia, North Korea, Syria, and innumerable other offenders against human rights. But for anti-Semites, only Israel in all the world is to be condemned.
There are two main sources of contemporary anti-Semitism, particularly of hatred of the Jewish People and of their homeland, Israel. One source is the "progressive" left, which dominates higher education, especially in the social sciences, humanities, and education. Remarkably, after Marxism failed in the world, having mainly produced despotism, poverty, and death, it was wholeheartedly adopted in Western academia as the new Truth.[viii] Marxism-Leninism became the framework through which Western academics viewed the world. After celebrations of classical Marxist class struggle which never arrived, attention turned to Lenin's imperialism theories, and become the dominant model, under such labels as political economy, globalization, political ecology, and, most popular, post-colonialism. This approach is applied to the Jewish state, arguing that Israel was a Western colony, that it was an imperialist settler state, oppressing and supplanting the "indigenous" Palestinians, and, in the last weeks, that it is a white, supremacist state.
Professors and academic organizations do not boycott North Korea, Iran, Syria, or even ISIS.
This is the account of Israel taught by many professors in Western colleges and universities. In my own faculty, dozens of professors from Anthropology, Political Science, Islamic Studies, History, and other departments published a letter announcing that they took this view of Israel, and supported BDS. In the BDS vote held last year by the American Anthropological Association, almost half of those voting favoured a boycott of Israel. In contrast, no boycotts were proposed by professor or academic organizations for China, North Korea, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Turkey, Syria, or even the Islamic State.
Nothing in the Marxist, postcolonial model actually fits Israel. As is well known, Jews occupied the entire area of ancient Judea and Israel, and were the only people there when the Romans invaded prior to the birth of Christ. It was, after all, the Romans who renamed the country "Palestine," to erase the memory of the Jews who fought a resistance against the Romans for two centuries. As for modern Israel, no Western country sent Jews as a colony to their ancient homeland in Palestine; rather, Europeans, especially the British, did everything they could to keep Jews from emigrating for Palestine. As for being Western and white, half of all Israeli Jews are of mizrahi or Sephardic origin, that is, of Middle Eastern origin.[ix] This does not include the Israelis of East Asian, South Asian, and Ethiopian origins, who add to the total of non-European Jews. Arabs came relatively late to Palestine, in the 7th century, replacing the Roman Byzantines who replaced the Western Romans. Today, Arabs make up around 20% of Israelis, most of whom are Israeli citizens, and of whom around 80% are Muslims.[x] All citizens of Israel have the same legal status. All can vote in the only democracy in the Middle East. Arabs have positions in all professions and institutions, governmental and civilian.[xi] Accusations of apartheid are risible.
The second source of contemporary anti-Semitism is the Arab ethno-nationalist and Muslim supremacist right. Students for Justice in Palestine[xii] and the Muslim Students Association[xiii] are vocal opponents of the Jewish State, and are the organizers and supporters of the BDS movement, often using Western rhetoric of democracy and human rights to advance their war on Israel. Underlying Western rhetoric is a substratum of traditional Islamic anti-Semitism[xiv] which fuels the anger against the Jews. One example is the Facebook post supporting an anti-Israel event at the University of Ontario Institute of Technology calling Jews "rodents."[xv]
It is standard fare in mosques to hear Jews characterized as "sons of pigs and apes."[xvi]
Sheikh Muhammad ibn Musa Al Nasr
Sheikh Muhammad ibn Musa Al Nasr
Normal too is the call to murder Jews: Canadian authorities are searching for a Muslim preacher, Sheikh Muhammad ibn Musa Al Nasr, after issuing an arrest warrant on hate crime charges in July 2017 after he gave a sermon calling for the murder of Jews.
The Montreal Gazette reported that Sheikh Muhammad ibn Musa Al Nasr is wanted after giving a sermon in the local Dar Al-Arqam Mosque late last year in which he called Jews "the worst of mankind."
Al Nasr also described Jews as "human demons" and said he looked forward to Judgment Day, the end of days, when they would be destroyed. He quoted a Hadith, verses which codify Muslim oral tradition, stating that at the end of time, "the stone and the tree will say: 'Oh Muslim, oh servant of Allah, there is a Jew behind me – come and kill him!'"[xvii]
Speaking officially, the Students for Justice in Palestine and the Muslim Students Association know to emphasize democracy, human rights, and compromise, as in the two state solution. But on marches and demonstrations, in their enthusiasm they chant "Palestine from the River to the Sea." Their real goal, admitted explicitly by Palestinian Hamas, Hezbollah, and Iran, and indicated in Arabic by the Palestinian Authority, is the destruction of Israel.
The idea that Jews could govern themselves, or even defend themselves, is anathema to Islamic supremacists.
There are multiple reasons for this: First, Jews in Muslim states were regarded as the lowest of the low, were ritually humiliated according to Islamic law, were required to pay a high tax to avoid being killed, and exploited in the variety of economic and other ways.[xviii] The idea that Jews could govern themselves independently, and even defend themselves, is anathema to the beloved identity of Islamic supremacy.[xix] Second, lands governed by Muslims–such as Palestine, first governed by Arabs, and then Turks–according to Islamic law become waqf, Islamic endowments, inalienable, owned by Muslims in perpetuity.[xx] To accept Israel, whether in 1948 or 1967 borders, would mean to allow Jews to steal God's land. Third, the repeated military defeat of Arab armies by Israeli Jews was a shameful loss of honour for Arab Muslims. Honour comes from victory; shame from defeat. To regain Arab and Muslim honour, Israel must be conquered, the Jews must be defeated.[xxi] BDS is presented as the more publicly acceptable goal of peace and justice, but the real intention behind it is conquest of Israel and defeat of the Jews, either killed or demoted to dependent dhimma status.
BDS is presented as a pursuit of peace and justice, but the real intention is conquest of Israel and defeat of the Jews.
The marriage of the progressive and Marxist left with the Arab ethno-nationalist and Muslim supremacist right in the war against Israel is remarkable, drawn together by an enemy that they can characterize as the essence of evil. In fact, having such an enemy is so attractive that feminists have joined, as has Black Lives Matter, bonded by intersectionality[xxii], as have various Protestant churches, such as the Quakers and Mennonites, and various marginal academic associations, such as the National Women's Studies Association, the Native American and Indigenous Studies Association, the Association for Asian-American Studies, and the Association for American Studies.[xxiii]
It seems odd, to say the least, that the most intense and vehement political campaign on Western university campuses once again targets the Jews. Some had thought, some had hoped, that after the Holocaust, the Jews were going to get a respite from being the universal scapegoat. But that did not happen. Once Jews were no longer victims, they came to be condemned because they were victors. No longer sympathized as failures, they became despised as successes. And we in higher education could enjoy our self-righteousness in condemning them. Always a useful people, the Jews, one way or another.
Philip Carl Salzman is a professor of anthropology at McGill University and a fellow at the Middle East Forum.
[iii] http://nationalpost.com/news/canada/mcgill-student-council-again-in-turmoil-after-jewish-student-removed-from-board-over-bds-issue; http://www.cjnews.com/perspectives/opinions/bds-campaign-stop-jews-serving-mcgill-student-council
[xiv] The Legacy of Islamic Antisemitism: From Sacred Texts to Solemn History, by Andrew G. Bostom (Editor), Ibn Warraq (Foreword). Prometheus Books, 2008; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islam_and_antisemitism
[xvi] "The Sons of Pigs and Apes": Muslim Antisemitism and the Conspiracy of Silence by Neil J. Kressel. Potomac Books, 2012