Related Topics

• Iran

Middle East Quarterly

• Dissident Watch: Abdul Rahman al-Lahim
  by Nathaniel Rosenblatt
• "A Land without a People for a People without a Land"
  by Diana Muir

Get Involved with the MEF

• Campus Activities
• Donations
• Employment & Internships

Articles by MEF Staff

• Middle East Studies in Fiction
  by Cinnamon Stillwell
• A Schism over Shari'a in the Church of England
  by David J. Rusin

MEF Wires

• What's at Stake for the West in Lebanon?
  by David Wurmser
• Culture and Conflict in the Middle East
  by Philip Carl Salzman

Forthcoming Events

• Lawrence Freedman:
  U.S. Involvement in the Middle East: The Origin and Consequences
  
• Douglas Feith:
  War and Decision
  

Press Releases

• Job Announcement: "Islamist Watch" Assistant Director
  
• Middle East Forum Launches "Islamist Watch" Website
  

FALL 2002 • VOLUME IX: NUMBER 4

Subscribe   |    Archive   |    Submit Manuscript   |    Board of Editors   |    Contact Editor   |

Iran at the Crossroads

Edited by John Esposito and R.K. Ramazani. New York: Palgrave, 2001. 248 pp.$49.95.

Reviewed by Patrick Clawson

Middle East Quarterly
Fall 2002

Print

Send

RSS

Optimism was in the air following Muhammad Khatami's surprise 1997 election as president of Iran. Surely the overwhelming public support for reform—reinforced repeatedly in elections since—would over time transform Iran, with the hard-line Islamists forced to retreat. The only issue was how quickly and smoothly the transition would go. This volume, the product of a 1999 conference, offers the definitive statement of that upbeat vision.

Unfortunately for the authors, reality subsequently dealt harsh blows to that vision, with Iran's hard-liners reasserting their control and stripping authority away from elected officials. The contributors' confidence in progress towards a liberal, moderate Iran now appears hopelessly naïve. Recounting the factional disputes in Iranian politics, Mohsen Milani is confident that the reform cause will grow stronger and stronger. Farideh Farhi exults, "for the first time in modern Iranian history, a substantial part of the Iranian population is engaged in a political discussion"—but soon after she wrote, the hard-liners shut the newspapers in which that discussion took place. Bijan Khahehpour maintains that in the economy, pragmatism triumphed over revolutionary fundamentalism, whereas the main trend of the last three years has been increased corruption, which has even spread to the oil industry, slowing the hoped-for foreign investment.

Some essays consist of the usual apologetics and U.S.-bashing. Fred Halliday and Mohiaddin Mesbahi argue in separate essays that Iran's foreign policy is pragmatic and non-ideological, which leaves this reader wondering how they explain Tehran's arming of Palestinian terrorists. Gary Sick argues that the United States and Iran are each self-righteous and ideologically rigid; sure, and U.S. inflexibility lay behind the 1984 initiative to sell Iran arms as a way to cultivate favor. At least R.K. Ramazani, for all his optimism, has the good sense in the final essay to write that only time will tell if the Islamic Republic will become compatible with the modern world.

Related Topics: Iran

To receive articles regularly by email, join the MEF News mailing list.
To receive the full, printed version of the Middle East Quarterly, please see details about an affordable subscription.

Related Items

• Other items from the Fall 2002 Middle East Quarterly
• Other items by Patrick Clawson